Solar energy collectors are basically distinguished by their motion such as fixed, single axes and two axis. The top surface of the absorber plate is coated with either a dark colored material or with a selective absorbent coating that is designed to extract as much as 15% more heat for the same active area. Flat plate collectors vs evacuated tube collectors simple solar. The use of solar energy for domestic hot water and steam generation in industry is economical and environmentally friendly. Flatplates can actually rob the water of built up heat if the collector becomes colder than the water temperature.
Based upon solar insolation of 861wm2 and an ambient temperature of 19. The flat plate solar collector is a type of solar thermal panel whose objective is to transform solar radiation into thermal energy. This acts as a source of insulation, reducing heat losses from the collector and making the product very efficient. Etc10 solar collector etc30c usa only flat plate solar collectors thermosiphon water heater pump stations. How flat plate solar collector workprinciple of fivestar flat plate. There are different solar collector types such as flat plate, evacuated and concentrated. In general, fixed collectors are used due to economical factors. Design and performance of evacuated solar collector.
Whether you have just purchased your collector or are researching before you buy you have taken an important step to reducing pollution and carbon dioxide emission, whilst enjoying piping hot water heated by nature. Evacuated tubes tend to be 1015% more expensive than flat plates, but their processing costs are dropping. Validated trnsys model for forced circulation solar water. Freestanding collector designed for use with flat roof applications. Feb 09, 2015 copper is more expensive, but is a better conductor and less prone to corrosion than aluminum. Evacuated tubes a brief overview since their conception, the evacuated tube collector has been commonly heralded around the solar industry as the more efficient collector. The thermal insulation prevents heat loss during fluid transfer. Evacuated tubes capture sunlight better as they have a greater surface area exposed to sun at any time. All solar collectors, evacuated tubes, flat plate collectors and unglazed pool heaters have different efficiencies. Comparison sheet evacuated heat pipe collectors versus flat.
Flat plate versus evacuated tubes solar water heating. Comparative analysis of selected flat plate collectors. Characteristic values of flatplate and evacuated tube collectors qcoll is the energy collected per unit collector area per unit time fr is the collectors heat removal factor. A large plate of blackened material is oriented in such a manner that the solar energy that falls on the pl. Jul 22, 2010 should i choose evacuated tube or flat plate solar collector. The chart below shows that a 20tube evacuated tube collector absorbed 150,000 btus or 36% more energy than a 4x8 flat plate in january 2009. A flat plate panel has insulation at the back and sides, with glass on top, and isnt so efficient per square metre. A flat plate solar collector comprising a planar glazing and a rear housing formed into a number of semicircular cells to receive fintube absorbers with minimal direct contact, the glazing being a low iron glass with an antireflective exterior coating and a low emissivity interior coating, the glazing being directly supported by the rear housing cells, the interior wall of the rear housing. Watch this video to weigh up the pros and cons of flat panel versus evacuated tubes. An evacuatedtube collector contains several rows of glass tubes connected to a header pipe. Titanpower flat plate collectors do not come with hardware, but both flush and free standing tilt mounting hardware is available for every flat plate collector. A cross section of a single evacuated tube with absorber plate is shown in figure 4.
Goettl and called the solar heat collector and radiator for building roof. Solar energy is used for variety of heating systems such as domestic hot water systems and industrial applications. As already mentioned, the useful heat transfer is from the absorber plate to the heat transfer medium, qu. Welcome to the navitron evacuated tube solar collector.
The flat plate evacuated tube collector consists of multiples of evacuated glass tubes in which one or two axial fluid conduits are located axially and attached to a selective absorber plate. Flat plate collectors v evacuated tubes a brief overview. The hills esteem evacuated tube solar collector is on average 163. Should i choose evacuated tube or flat plate solar collector. Evacuated tube solar collectors are wellsuited to commercial laundromat and industrial heating applications and can be an effective alternative to flatplate collectors for domestic space heating, especially in areas where it is often cloudy.
The simplest design is that which contains one circular fluid conduit. Solar collectors are just one of the critical components of a solar hot water system. Schematic of a flat plate solar collector with liquid transport medium. Flat plate collector evacuated tube collector trnsys. Thermal performance of gasfilled flat plate solar collectors. This type of solar collector has a good cost effectiveness ratio in moderate climates and adapts correctly to a large number of applications of solar thermal energy heating of sanitary water, heating of swimming pools, support for heating, preheating industrial. Flat plate versus evacuated tubes solar water heating solar. Htps space heating boilers provide ultimate comfort and the best overall efficiency ratings while keeping maintenance and operating costs to a minimum. Flat plate thermal solar collectors are the most commonly used type of solar collector. Performance testing of evacuated tubular collectors page 7 of 81 3 thermal capacity of heat pipes and.
Solar energy is one of the alternatives to replace the use of conventional energy sources to heat water for domestic use. With a htp high efficiency boiler you can achieve the heat your family or. Characteristic values of flat plate and evacuated tube collectors qcoll is the energy collected per unit collector area per unit time fr is the collector s heat removal factor. Copper is more expensive, but is a better conductor and less prone to corrosion than aluminum. Most flatplate collectors have two horizontal pipes at the top and bottom, called headers, and many smaller vertical pipes connecting them, called risers.
This energy can be used for domestic and commercial hot water heating, pool heating, space heating or even air conditioning. For example in a cool climate, you could need 2 or 3 flat panel collectors to produce the same heat as 1 evacuated tube collector. This paper presents a validated trnsys model for forced circulation solar water heating systems used in temperate climates. Solar collector, thermal, vacuum, flat panel, heat transfer, heat recovery factor, optimisation, laminar flow, microchannel, pressure drop, pumping power, thermal expansion, laser weld. Solar evacuatedtube collectors, on the other hand, contain rows of tubes which are constructed by encasing metal absorber tubes inside transparent glass tubes. Evacuated tube solar collectors are very efficient and can achieve very high temperatures. Flat plate collectors often graphs comparing flat plate collectors with evacuated tube collectors are based on gross area, which shows the evacuated tube collector with a yintercept of only 4045%, and the flat plate around 7580%. This is why no one can say evacuated tubes are always better than flat plate collectors. This paper focuses on the design and fabrication of a second generation indigenized fpc with locally available low cost material and compares its performance with existing costlier etc solar water heating system. A standard glazed flat plate collector and an evacuated tube collector are installed in parallel and tested at the same working conditions. Flatplate solar thermal panels are comprised of an absorber and transparent layer, held within a frame and insulation.
The hills esteem evacuated tube solar collector is on average 51. Background solar thermal water heating or solar hot water shw has a long history of use throughout the world, but has had varying penetration in the u. Performance testing of evacuated tubular collectors page 2 of 81. This type of solar collector has a good cost effectiveness ratio in moderate climates and adapts correctly to a large number of applications of solar thermal energy heating of sanitary water, heating of swimming pools, support for. Flat plate collectors typically cost less from the outset than evacuated tubes. These collectors are fieldtested and ready for use in nearly all climates and locations. Flat plate solar collectors can be used in most climates, but are significantly more effective in warmer, sunnier, southern climates, where freezing and solar. Performance testing of evacuated tubular collectors. Comparative study of solar water heating systems flat. Comparison of evacuated tube and flat plate solar collector.
The principal component of a flat plate solar collector is the absorber plate, which consists of an assembly of a copper sheet and copper tubing. The solar radiation is absorbed by the black plate and transfers heat to the fluid in the tubes. Comparative study of solar water heating systems flat plate. Three bosch solar thermal collectors installed by apex thermal services, olivebridge, ny, ulster county this is a comparison of solar thermal flat plate collectors versus evacuated tube collectors i so love this comparison. The flatplate systems normally operate and reach the maximum efficiency within the temperature range from 30 to 80 o c kalogirou, 2009, however, some new types of collectors that employ vacuum insulation can achieve higher temperatures up to 100 o c. Feb 08, 20 1introduction 3 pages2flatplate collectors 5 a. In locations with average available solar energy, flat plate collectors are sized approximately onehalf to onesquare foot per gallon of onedays hot water use. Evacuated tube collectors use glass tubes in which a vacuum is created. The performance of heat pipes is the performance of heat pipes is determined by working fluid. So many folks out there are making huge claims about the efficiency of their solar hot water collectors, particularly evacuated tubes. Home solar products evacuated tube solar collectors evacuated tube solar collectors apricus etc evacuated tube solar collectors convert energy from the sun into usable heat in a solar water heating system. Flatplate collectors contain water and unless well protected can burst upon freezing. In really cold under 50f weather, flat panel collectors collect little or no heat. Comparison sheet evacuated heat pipe collectors versus.
Transient modelling showed absorber heat capacity to have a significant effect in winter but. Comparison of efficiencies and thermal outputs 23 how do collectors work in winter. Solar collectors are just one of the critical components of a. In these devices a glazed flat plate collector is mounted on insulated, weatherproofed boxes fitted with a dark absorber plate under one or more plastic or glass covers known as glazing. Performance and operational effectiveness of evacuated flat. Performance and operational effectiveness of evacuated. May 30, 2018 the flat plate solar collector is a type of solar thermal panel whose objective is to transform solar radiation into thermal energy. We have models from 26 ft2 up to 40 ft2, many of which are srcc og100 certified to maximize rebates and performance guarantees. Solar evacuated tube collectors, on the other hand, contain rows of tubes which are constructed by encasing metal absorber tubes inside transparent glass tubes. The solar flat plate collector can also be used to power a solar airconditioning system, and is capable of up to 15,200 btu of cooling per panel per day. The first solar thermal collector designed for building roofs was patented by william h. In these devices a glazed flatplate collector is mounted on insulated, weatherproofed boxes fitted with a dark absorber plate under one or more plastic or glass covers known as glazing. They can be very expensive compared to flat plate collectors or batch solar collectors, though some of the integrated tank collectors are the cheapest to purchase and operate as they dont need most of the balanceofsystem components.
During collector field trials conducted in okotoks, alberta a flat panel collector and an evacuated tube collector were mounted side by side, tilted at 45 degrees, and facing due south. Apricus evacuated tube vs flat plate comparing apricus evacuated tube and high performance flat plate collectors often graphs comparing flat plate collectors with evacuated tube collectors are based on gross area, which shows the evacuated tube collector with a yintercept of only 4045%, and the flat plate around 7580%. Introduction conventional solar collectors use either a flat panel design or an evacuated tube design. This can be very deceptive making it look like the flat plate is almost twice as efficient. Very good solar radiation 600 wm2, outside temperature 10oc, absorber temperature 40oc, no snow or frost on the surface doublewall evacuated tube collectors also in winter achieve lower solar yields than flat plate collectors despite lower heat. There are different solar collector types such as flatplate, evacuated and concentrated. Bhatia, in advanced renewable energy systems, 2014. Our evacuated tube collector is suited for residential, commercial, and industrial applications. Generally, evacuated tubes perform better in colder andor cloudier conditions than their flat panel counterparts.
391 158 1320 897 818 1529 885 1165 1212 832 415 640 26 831 1498 653 379 1176 44 1530 11 566 178 940 484 752 253 84 172 441 1432 741 1127 923 1054 167 637 1107 209 650 1438 1082 52 639 820